Skip to main content

Table 3 Meta-analysis results

From: Associations between diabetic retinopathy, mortality, disease, and mental health: an umbrella review of observational meta-analyses

Arial

8

Study type(s)

Total included studies

Total participants

Effect size type

Effect size (95% CI)

p

I2

Small study effect

Excess significance bias

PI

Level of evidence

Mortality

All-cause mortality

Cohort

18

19,813

RR

2.37

(2.02–2.78)

 < 1–6

42.31

Yes

No

1.50–3.73

Grade II

CVD mortality in all DR

10

11,239

RR

1.83

(1.42–2.36)

 < 1–6

76.28

No

Yes

0.81–4.13

Grade II

CVD mortality in mild DR

4

7,361

RR

1.14

(0.81–1.58)

0.45

63.24

No

NS

0.30–4.29

NS

CVD mortality in severe DR

6

9,691

RR

2.26

(1.31–3.91)

 < 1–6

84.96

No

No

0.37–13.8

Grade II

Disease

Obstructive sleep apnoea

Case–control

6

1,092

OR

2.16

(1.35–3.44)

0.001

52.12

No

No

0.57–8.74

Grade II

Chronic kidney disease

Cohort

2

781

OR

2.73

(0.37–19.95)

0.32

97.22

No

NS

NA

NS

Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease all DR

Cross-sectional

8

7,170

OR

1.00

(0.48–2.10)

1.00

96.65

Yes

NS

0.07–14.9

NS

Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease non-proliferative DR

3

3,977

OR

0.74

(0.37–1.50)

0.40

95.25

No

NS

0.00–5561.39

NS

Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease proliferative DR

3

3,977

OR

0.96

(0.21–4.28)

0.96

96.53

No

NS

0.00–162,240,006.20

NS

Primary open angle glaucoma

Cohort

2

241,037

OR

1.47

(0.57–3.77)

0.42

95.45

No

NS

NA

NS

Cross-sectional

4

15,389

OR

1.01

(0.56–1.81)

0.98

84.32

No

NS

0.07–14.14

NS

Mental Health

Depression (Type I)†

Case–control

3

971

OR

2.19

(0.91–5.24)

0.08

84.99

Yes

NS

0.00–86,679.18

NS

Depression (Type 2) †

Cross-sectional

9

31,766

OR

1.62

(1.37–1.91)

 < 1–6

43.36

No

Yes

1.09–2.41

Grade II

Eating disorders

Cross-sectional

7

1,091

OR

2.81

(1.67–4.72)

 < 1–6

35.21

No

No

0.82–9.63

Grade II

Alzheimer’s

Cohort

2

46,185

OR

1.56

(1.16–2.08)

0.003

0.00

Yes

No

NA

Grade IV

Dementia

Cohort

3

7,754

OR

1.46

(1.09–1.94)

0.01

73.64

No

No

0.05–39.66

Grade IV

Cognitive impairment

Cross-sectional

5

2,451

OR

2.07

(1.11–3.88)

0.02

60.03

No

No

0.28–15.06

Grade IV

Cohort

5

1,397

OR

2.71

(1.90–3.87)

 < 1–6

0.02

Yes

No

1.90–3.87

Grade II

  1. † Depression was the only outcome that stratified by type of diabetes – all other outcomes were mixed