Author, year | Selection of exposed and non-exposed from same population? | Can we be confident in the assessment of exposure? | Outcome of interest was not present at start of the study? | The study matched exposed and non-exposed for all the variables associated with the outcome of interest or did the statistical analysis adjust for these prognostic variables? | Can we be confident in the assessment of absence and presence of prognostic factors? | Can we be confident in the assessment of outcome? | Was the follow-up of cohorts adequate? | Were con-interventions similar between groups? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kuijpens, 2005 [8] | DY | DY | DY | DY | DY | DY | PN | DY |
Hellevik, 2009 [15] | DY | DY | DY | PY | DY | DY | PY | PY |
Razvi, 2012 [16] | PY | DY | DY | PN | DY | DY | DY | PY |
Waring, 2012 [64] | DY | DY | DY | PY | PY | DY | DY | PY |
Tseng, 2015 [63] | PY | DY | DY | PY | DY | DY | DY | PY |
Fighera, 2015 [61] | DN | DY | PN | PN/PY | DY | DY | PY | PY |
Pinter, 2017 [62] | DY | DY | DY | PN | DY | DY | PY | PY |