Skip to main content

Table 1 Inclusion and exclusion criteria

From: Using mHealth applications for self-care – An integrative review on perceptions among adults with type 1 diabetes

Inclusion Criteria

Exclusion criteria

1. Studies with adults (≥ 18 years)

2. Type 1 diabetes

3. Studies focusing on mHealth appsa

4. Studies carried out in any country and settings (such as primary care, outpatient or community settings)

5. Published in peer reviewed scientific journals

6. Published in English

1. Studies focusing on mHealth apps for diabetes prevention or pre-diabetes or type 2 diabetes

2. Studies with pregnant women or children with diabetes as the study population

3. mHealth apps addressing single self-care domains like physical activity, diet management, educational aspects or psychosocial aspects alone

4. Studies focusing on reviewing apps in application stores, review studies, technical design, or technical evaluation of mHealth apps (irrelevant study designs)

5. Studies conducted before 2010

6. Studies with software applications that are solely web-based and can only be accessed through an internet browser application in the mobile device

7. Studies where the outcomes of interest were not measured or reported or were irrelevant (common irrelevant outcomes were for example HbA1C, time or percentage time in target blood sugar range, quality adjusted life years, economic outcomes etc.)

  1. a mHealth apps here are defined as software applications run on mobile devices (smartphone, tablet, or smartwatch etc.) and operated by people with type 1 diabetes for self-monitoring of parameters, specifically Blood glucose and/or Insulin dose or Insulin bolus calculation, were included. Additional monitoring features such as tracking diet, exercise, mood, graphical trends, alerts to deviant values, diabetes education, and feedback from health care professionals are desirable but not necessary for inclusion. Devices like connected automated insulin delivery systems, app-based therapeutic decision support, flash or continuous glucose monitors etc. when accompanied by the use of a software applications run on a mobile or handheld devices was considered for inclusion